• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Security
  • Education
  • Sports
  • Health
  • Entertainment
  • Legal
  • Technology and Science
  • Opinion
  • Columns
  • Exposé
  • World
  • Lifestyle
DNA Test Is Not The Only Proof Of Paternity Under Nigerian Law!

DNA Test Is Not The Only Proof Of Paternity Under Nigerian Law!

1 year ago
Rwandan President Breaks Silence On UK Asylum Deal

Rwandan, DR Congo Leaders In Talks Over Clashes In Eastern DRC

4 hours ago
Hundreds Of Boko Haram Terrorists Missing After jailbreak In Nigeria

Nigeria: ISWAP Claims Responsibility For Attack On Kuje Prison, Release Video Evidence

4 hours ago
Cuba Consortium Signs Agreement To Establish Vaccines Manufacturing Plant In Nigeria, Bayelsa State

Cuba Consortium Signs Agreement To Establish Vaccines Manufacturing Plant In Nigeria, Bayelsa State

4 hours ago
NCDMB
ADVERTISEMENT
Missing NAF Aircraft: CAS Relocates To Maiduguri

Again, Nigerian Air Force Jet ‘Mistakenly’ Bombs Katsina Community

4 hours ago
Nigerian Students In Northern Cyprus Cry Out Over Maltreatment

Nigerian Students In Northern Cyprus Cry Out Over Maltreatment

5 hours ago
Nollywood Actress, Funke Akindele Emerges Lagos PDP Deputy Governorship Candidate

Nollywood Actress, Funke Akindele Emerges Lagos PDP Deputy Governorship Candidate

6 hours ago
Unemployment Driving Malawian Nurses To Saudi Arabia, US — Group

Unemployment Driving Malawian Nurses To Saudi Arabia, US — Group

6 hours ago
Sterling Nears City Exit, Set To Become Chelsea’s Highest Paid Player

Sterling Nears City Exit, Set To Become Chelsea’s Highest Paid Player

7 hours ago
Asisat Oshoala Ruled Out Of WAFCON

Asisat Oshoala Ruled Out Of WAFCON

8 hours ago
Nigerian Singer, Eedris Abdulkareem Battling Kidney Failure, Set To Undergo Transplant

Nigerian Singer, Eedris Abdulkareem Battling Kidney Failure, Set To Undergo Transplant

10 hours ago
JUST IN: President Buhari Stops Over At Kuje Prison Ahead Of Senegal Trip

JUST IN: President Buhari Stops Over At Kuje Prison Ahead Of Senegal Trip

11 hours ago
European Parliament Backs Listing Gas, Nuclear Energy As ‘Green’

European Parliament Backs Listing Gas, Nuclear Energy As ‘Green’

12 hours ago
DR Congo On Brink Of War With Rwanda, Says President Tshisekedi

DR Congo On Brink Of War With Rwanda, Says President Tshisekedi

12 hours ago
Hundreds Of Boko Haram Terrorists Missing After jailbreak In Nigeria

Hundreds Of Boko Haram Terrorists Missing After jailbreak In Nigeria

12 hours ago
Nigeria: President Buhari Reshuffles Cabinet As 7 New Ministers Take Oath Of Office

Nigeria: President Buhari Reshuffles Cabinet As 7 New Ministers Take Oath Of Office

12 hours ago
Match-fixing: Sierra Leone FA Investigates ‘Impractical’ 91-1 And 95-0 Scoreline

Match-fixing: Sierra Leone FA Investigates ‘Impractical’ 91-1 And 95-0 Scoreline

13 hours ago
Naira Records Biggest Fall Against US Dollar 

Naira Records Biggest Fall Against US Dollar 

15 hours ago
Uganda Adopts Swahili As Official Language

Uganda Adopts Swahili As Official Language

15 hours ago
Bayelsa West Groups Commend Senator Dickson

Bayelsa West Groups Commend Senator Dickson

18 hours ago
OPEC Sec-General, Muhammad Barkindo Is Dead

OPEC Sec-General, Muhammad Barkindo Is Dead

20 hours ago
ADVERTISEMENT
Thursday, July 7, 2022
  • Photo Speaks
  • Videos
  • You-Report
  • Whistleblower
  • Advertise
  • HT Events
  • About HT
  • Contact
The Heritage Times
No Result
View All Result
Translate | EN FR
  • Login
  • Politics
    Tunisia Constitution Committee Head Condemns President’s Latest Draft

    Tunisia Constitution Committee Head Condemns President’s Latest Draft

    Nigeria: Seven Things You Should Know As Voter Registration Continues

    Nigeria: Seven Things You Should Know As Voter Registration Continues

    Tunisia Constitution Committee Head Condemns President’s Latest Draft

    Tunisia Draft Constitution Widens President’s Powers

    Israeli Parliament Dissolves Itself, Sets November 1 Election

    Israeli Parliament Dissolves Itself, Sets November 1 Election

    Sudan's Military Cuts Off Internet Ahead Of Protests

    Sudan’s Military Cuts Off Internet Ahead Of Protests

    Nigerian Deputy Senate President Picks 42-Year-Old Osanebi As Running Mate For Delta State Guber Election

    Nigerian Deputy Senate President Picks 42-Year-Old Osanebi As Running Mate For Delta State Guber Election

    Insecurity: Drop Your Pride, Seek Foreign Help! - Ekweremadu Tells FG

    Alleged Organ Harvesting: Nigeria’s Senate Dispatches Delegates To UK

    Use Your Talent To Improve National Unity - Jonathan Urges Young Nigerians

    Nigeria: Why I Didn’t Implement Report Of 2014 National Conference – Ex-President Jonathan

    JUST IN: Justice Ariwoola Sworn In As Acting Chief Justice Of Nigeria

    JUST IN: Justice Ariwoola Sworn In As Acting Chief Justice Of Nigeria

  • Economy
    European Parliament Backs Listing Gas, Nuclear Energy As ‘Green’

    European Parliament Backs Listing Gas, Nuclear Energy As ‘Green’

    Naira Records Biggest Fall Against US Dollar 

    Naira Records Biggest Fall Against US Dollar 

    Nigerian Govt To Maximize Local Content Opportunities In Midstream/Downstream Sectors

    62% Of Nigerians Lack Access To Electricity- Sylva

    OPEC Reviews Oil Production Quota For Countries

    Oil Supply From Venezuela, Iran Can Ease Off Energy Crisis — OPEC

    Zimbabwe To Introduce Gold Coins As Local Currency Tumbles

    Zimbabwe To Introduce Gold Coins As Local Currency Tumbles

    Nigeria Must Upscale Local Capabilities To Achieve Energy Security — NCDMB Boss

    Nigeria Must Upscale Local Capabilities To Achieve Energy Security — NCDMB Boss

    JPMorgan Predicts ‘Stratospheric’ $380 Oil Price Surge If Moscow Retaliate Sanctions

    JPMorgan Predicts ‘Stratospheric’ $380 Oil Price Surge If Moscow Retaliate Sanctions

    NCDMB, NAICOM Present Insurance Services Guidelines To Oil And Gas Stakeholders

    NCDMB, NAICOM Present Insurance Services Guidelines To Oil And Gas Stakeholders

    Algeria Hikes Price Of Gas Exports Amid More Demand From Europe

    Algeria Hikes Price Of Gas Exports Amid More Demand From Europe

  • Security
  • Education
  • Sports
  • Health
  • Metro
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Legal
  • Tech & Science
  • Opinion
  • Exposé
  • Exclusive Videos
  • Niger Delta
  • World
  • Politics
    Tunisia Constitution Committee Head Condemns President’s Latest Draft

    Tunisia Constitution Committee Head Condemns President’s Latest Draft

    Nigeria: Seven Things You Should Know As Voter Registration Continues

    Nigeria: Seven Things You Should Know As Voter Registration Continues

    Tunisia Constitution Committee Head Condemns President’s Latest Draft

    Tunisia Draft Constitution Widens President’s Powers

    Israeli Parliament Dissolves Itself, Sets November 1 Election

    Israeli Parliament Dissolves Itself, Sets November 1 Election

    Sudan's Military Cuts Off Internet Ahead Of Protests

    Sudan’s Military Cuts Off Internet Ahead Of Protests

    Nigerian Deputy Senate President Picks 42-Year-Old Osanebi As Running Mate For Delta State Guber Election

    Nigerian Deputy Senate President Picks 42-Year-Old Osanebi As Running Mate For Delta State Guber Election

    Insecurity: Drop Your Pride, Seek Foreign Help! - Ekweremadu Tells FG

    Alleged Organ Harvesting: Nigeria’s Senate Dispatches Delegates To UK

    Use Your Talent To Improve National Unity - Jonathan Urges Young Nigerians

    Nigeria: Why I Didn’t Implement Report Of 2014 National Conference – Ex-President Jonathan

    JUST IN: Justice Ariwoola Sworn In As Acting Chief Justice Of Nigeria

    JUST IN: Justice Ariwoola Sworn In As Acting Chief Justice Of Nigeria

  • Economy
    European Parliament Backs Listing Gas, Nuclear Energy As ‘Green’

    European Parliament Backs Listing Gas, Nuclear Energy As ‘Green’

    Naira Records Biggest Fall Against US Dollar 

    Naira Records Biggest Fall Against US Dollar 

    Nigerian Govt To Maximize Local Content Opportunities In Midstream/Downstream Sectors

    62% Of Nigerians Lack Access To Electricity- Sylva

    OPEC Reviews Oil Production Quota For Countries

    Oil Supply From Venezuela, Iran Can Ease Off Energy Crisis — OPEC

    Zimbabwe To Introduce Gold Coins As Local Currency Tumbles

    Zimbabwe To Introduce Gold Coins As Local Currency Tumbles

    Nigeria Must Upscale Local Capabilities To Achieve Energy Security — NCDMB Boss

    Nigeria Must Upscale Local Capabilities To Achieve Energy Security — NCDMB Boss

    JPMorgan Predicts ‘Stratospheric’ $380 Oil Price Surge If Moscow Retaliate Sanctions

    JPMorgan Predicts ‘Stratospheric’ $380 Oil Price Surge If Moscow Retaliate Sanctions

    NCDMB, NAICOM Present Insurance Services Guidelines To Oil And Gas Stakeholders

    NCDMB, NAICOM Present Insurance Services Guidelines To Oil And Gas Stakeholders

    Algeria Hikes Price Of Gas Exports Amid More Demand From Europe

    Algeria Hikes Price Of Gas Exports Amid More Demand From Europe

  • Security
  • Education
  • Sports
  • Health
  • Metro
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Legal
  • Tech & Science
  • Opinion
  • Exposé
  • Exclusive Videos
  • Niger Delta
  • World
No Result
View All Result
Morning News
ADVERTISEMENT
Home Opinion

DNA Test Is Not The Only Proof Of Paternity Under Nigerian Law!

By Prof Obiaraeri

January 16, 2021
in Opinion, Legal, Top Stories
0
DNA Test Is Not The Only Proof Of Paternity Under Nigerian Law!

Prof Obiaraeri.

15
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Whatsapp
ADVERTISEMENT

I have had the privilege of reading an earlier intervention by Durotimi David Owoeye Esq titled “DNA TEST AS PROOF OF PATERNITY: THE CURRENT POSITION OF NIGERIAN LAW”, wherein he ably captured the position of only one out of the two systems of laws applicable in Nigeria on use of DNA as proof of paternity.

Amidst rising rates of infidelity including paternity fraud in Nigeria and in view of heightened public interest generated by the controversial issue of recourse to DNA as proof of paternity, it has become expedient to balance the narrative by exposing how paternity can be proved under yet another branch of Nigerian law, being customary law.

Relatedreading

Nigeria: ISWAP Claims Responsibility For Attack On Kuje Prison, Release Video Evidence

Cuba Consortium Signs Agreement To Establish Vaccines Manufacturing Plant In Nigeria, Bayelsa State

It bears repeating that the said article by Owoeye Esq did not address proof of paternity under customary law and has as such left many members of the reading public to think that DNA test is the only acceptable method of proof of paternity under Nigerian law.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

The following may therefore be noted as a more comprehensive treatment of the subject matter of proof of paternity covering the dual systems of laws (statutory and customary) applicable in Nigeria.

1. The preliminary point must be made that customary law (including Islamic or Sharia law) is not inferior to received English law except where such customary law is shown to be barbaric being that it is proved to be repugnant to natural justice, equity and good conscience, incompatible with public policy or at variance with any provisions of a statute.

2. DNA test as proof of paternity is foreign, alien or unknown to indigenous customary law usages.

3. To prove paternity under customary law, what is needed is evidence of a subsisiting marriage.

Thus, DNA test is not needed to prove paternity if there is a clear evidence of valid and subsisting marriage under customary law.

This is also true of English law although customary law position on proof of paternity is more accommodating and can even be said to be in sync with the right to freedom from discrimination guaranteed under section 42(2) of the 1999 Constitution as amended to the effect that “No citizen of Nigeria shall be subjected to any disability or deprivation merely by reason of the circumstances of his birth”.

4. Customary law protects family bond and privacy rights and jealously guards the marriage institution to the extent that no offspring of a valid marriage is to be discriminated against on account of the circumstance of his or her birth.

For instance, this is the general principle espoused in the Igbo customary proverb on paternity- “ebe nwa shiri lo uwa ya hiri”.

5. Under customary law, paternity dispute is never between a husband and a male adulterer because the fact of valid and subsisting marriage creates the strong presumption of paternity in favour of parties to the marriage.

Any child born during wedlock is presumed to be the product of that marriage.

6. Under customary law, where there is no marriage between the parties, (being between a woman and a man entangled with her in amorous or illicit love affair) paternity dispute may never arise, and if it does, it is easily dismissed by the strong saying- “enyi anaghi enwe nwa”.

This is true, at least in Igbo land.

When literally intepreted into English, this means that a person who is not married to a woman but otherwise laying claim to paternity of a child via illicit or amorous relationship may not succeed in a claim for paternity if the woman or her family resist it.

7. Paternity can also be acknowledged under customary law usages, thus ruling out DNA test completely.

This customary law principle of “acknowledgement of parernity” posits that one does not to be the biological father of a child or to be married to the child’s mother to be the father of the child.

8. It needs to be restated that both under the received English law and Customary laws applicable in Nigeria, the fact of valid and subsisting marriage raises a presumption of paternity of children born within wedlock.

9. Based on the presumption raised in paragraph 8 above, an outsider (being a male adulterer), cannot successfully claim paternity of a child during the pendency of a lawful marriage without exposing himself to legal action for damages for adultery.

10. Even with DNA test applicable to marriages celebrated under the Act, the decision of the Court of Appeal in the case of TONY ANOZIA v MRS. PATRICIA OKWUNWA NNANI & IGNATIUS “NNANI” (2015) 8 NWLR (Pt. 1461) 241 as correctly stated by Owoeye Esq is that the court can only order a DNA test with respect to minors and not adults. “Where a person is a minor (not mature adult) and his paternity is in issue, the court can order the conduct of DNA test in the overall interest of the child, to ascertain where he belongs”.

11. The courts will not order DNA test to determine the paternity of a full blown adult who does not complain about his parenthood as that will be a clear violation of the right to privacy.

An adult may simply be equated to anyone above 18 years of age, being the age of eligibility to vote in Nigeria.

The adult can however waive his right to undergo DNA test but a volunteer can not complain later- violenti non fit injuria.

12. Whether under English law or customary law, where a child is born within wedlock, the PRESUMPTION is conclusive that the “child is the seed or product of the marriage.”

This submission is duly supported by the combined reading of the provisions of sections 165 and 166 of the Evidence Act.

13. Nigerians are increasingly becoming agitated by the disturbing development where some foreign Embassies resort to the requirement of DNA test from couples as a precondition for issuance of their family visas and other forms of immigration requests in circumstances that do not accommodate the customary law position on paternity in Nigeria.

It is submitted that this practice although within the threshold of sovereignty is a clear violation of the rights to privacy and freedom from discrimination generously guaranteed under the Nigerian Constitution as amended, articles of the African Charter and International Bill on Human Rights.

14. Conclusively, DNA test is not the only way to prove paternity under Nigerian law.

DNA test suffices for proof of paternity in marriages celebrated under the Marriage Act but does not extinguish or trump other forms of proof of paternity under customary law.

A new normal is possible!

🖋️Wriiten By Prof Obiaraeri, N.O. Ph.D (Law), B L., etc.

ShareTweetSendShare
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

WAFU U 17: Golden Eaglets cruise to Final after beating Burkina Faso 1 – 0

Next Post

Taaooma Reacts To Allegations of N1.5 Million Skit

Related Posts

Hundreds Of Boko Haram Terrorists Missing After jailbreak In Nigeria

Nigeria: ISWAP Claims Responsibility For Attack On Kuje Prison, Release Video Evidence

July 6, 2022
Cuba Consortium Signs Agreement To Establish Vaccines Manufacturing Plant In Nigeria, Bayelsa State

Cuba Consortium Signs Agreement To Establish Vaccines Manufacturing Plant In Nigeria, Bayelsa State

July 6, 2022

Again, Nigerian Air Force Jet ‘Mistakenly’ Bombs Katsina Community

Nigerian Students In Northern Cyprus Cry Out Over Maltreatment

Unemployment Driving Malawian Nurses To Saudi Arabia, US — Group

JUST IN: President Buhari Stops Over At Kuje Prison Ahead Of Senegal Trip

Next Post
Taaooma Reacts To Allegations of N1.5 Million Skit

Taaooma Reacts To Allegations of N1.5 Million Skit

Discussion about this post

Heritage Bank

Updates

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Elon Musk’s Child Files To Change Gender, Name And End Relationship With Father

Elon Musk’s Child Files To Change Gender, Name And End Relationship With Father

June 21, 2022
Hundreds Of Boko Haram Terrorists Missing After jailbreak In Nigeria

Nigeria: Boko Haram Kills 17 Officers, Abducts 4 Chinese Expatriates In Attempt To Seize Shiroro Power Station

June 30, 2022
Nigeria’s Economy Worse Under Buhari Than It Was 10 Years Ago- World Bank

JUST IN: Gunmen Attack President Buhari’s Advance Convoy In Katsina

July 5, 2022
JUST IN: Terrorists Launch Attack On Kuje Maximum Prison In Abuja

JUST IN: Terrorists Launch Attack On Kuje Maximum Prison In Abuja

July 5, 2022
Rwandan President Breaks Silence On UK Asylum Deal

Rwandan, DR Congo Leaders In Talks Over Clashes In Eastern DRC

July 6, 2022
Hundreds Of Boko Haram Terrorists Missing After jailbreak In Nigeria

Nigeria: ISWAP Claims Responsibility For Attack On Kuje Prison, Release Video Evidence

July 6, 2022
Cuba Consortium Signs Agreement To Establish Vaccines Manufacturing Plant In Nigeria, Bayelsa State

Cuba Consortium Signs Agreement To Establish Vaccines Manufacturing Plant In Nigeria, Bayelsa State

July 6, 2022
Missing NAF Aircraft: CAS Relocates To Maiduguri

Again, Nigerian Air Force Jet ‘Mistakenly’ Bombs Katsina Community

July 6, 2022
NCDMB

Most Recent

Rwandan, DR Congo Leaders In Talks Over Clashes In Eastern DRC

July 6, 2022

Nigeria: ISWAP Claims Responsibility For Attack On Kuje Prison, Release Video Evidence

July 6, 2022

Cuba Consortium Signs Agreement To Establish Vaccines Manufacturing Plant In Nigeria, Bayelsa State

July 6, 2022

Again, Nigerian Air Force Jet ‘Mistakenly’ Bombs Katsina Community

July 6, 2022

Nigerian Students In Northern Cyprus Cry Out Over Maltreatment

July 6, 2022

Nollywood Actress, Funke Akindele Emerges Lagos PDP Deputy Governorship Candidate

July 6, 2022

Unemployment Driving Malawian Nurses To Saudi Arabia, US — Group

July 6, 2022

Sterling Nears City Exit, Set To Become Chelsea’s Highest Paid Player

July 6, 2022
HOUSE FORTY THREE RESTAURANT
MOSILO GROUP
ADVERTISEMENT

About

The Heritage Times was established to advance transparency and accountability in leadership and governance. Our vision is to become Africa's foremost provider of quality news and contents. We seek to lead a news media revolution that will foster a sustainable democratic Africa.

Featured

Nigeria: Seven Things You Should Know As Voter Registration Continues

#ReformIELTSPolicy: UK Envoy’s Statement Justifies Advocacy For Nigeria’s IELTS Exemption, Says Group

Robert Azibaola: Saving Bayelsa’s Rainforests

Connect

Connect with us on social media and receive timely updates on the go.

Get Updates

    • About
    • Privacy Policy

    © 2022 The Heritage Times Media.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Welcome
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • Security
    • Exposé
    • Education
    • Sports
    • Health
    • Entertainment
    • Legal
    • Technology and Science
    • Opinion
    • Columns
    • World
    • __________________
    • Photo Speaks
    • Videos
    • You-Report
    • Whistleblower
    • Advertise
    • HT Events
    • About HT
    • Contact us

    © 2022 The Heritage Times Media.

    Welcome Back!

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password?

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In